"On the last day of the world I would want to plant a tree.” — W.S. Merwin
  • Above the Law?

    (2)
    Posted on January 31st, 2008sherryCurrent Events

    From the Boston Globe (emphasis mine):

    WASHINGTON – President Bush this week declared that he has the power to bypass four laws, including a prohibition against using federal funds to establish permanent US military bases in Iraq, that Congress passed as part of a new defense bill.

    Bush made the assertion in a signing statement that he issued late Monday after signing the National Defense Authorization Act for 2008. In the signing statement, Bush asserted that four sections of the bill unconstitutionally infringe on his powers, and so the executive branch is not bound to obey them.

    “Provisions of the act . . . purport to impose requirements that could inhibit the president’s ability to carry out his constitutional obligations to take care that the laws be faithfully executed, to protect national security, to supervise the executive branch, and to execute his authority as commander in chief,” Bush said. “The executive branch shall construe such provisions in a manner consistent with the constitutional authority of the President.”

    One section Bush targeted created a statute that forbids spending taxpayer money “to establish any military installation or base for the purpose of providing for the permanent stationing of United States Armed Forces in Iraq” or “to exercise United States control of the oil resources of Iraq.”

    The Bush administration is negotiating a long-term agreement with Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki. The agreement is to include the basing of US troops in Iraq after 2008, as well as security guarantees and other economic and political ties between the United States and Iraq.

    Link via Juan Cole.

    According to Think Progress, Bush has signed 151 of these statements challenging 1149 provisions of laws. Other provisions in the Defense Bill that Bush will ignore include:

    …a commission to probe contracting fraud in Iraq and Afghanistan. Another expands protections for whistleblowers who work for government contractors. A third requires that U.S. intelligence agencies promptly respond to congressional requests for documents…

    Bush seems to be trying to tie us up in Iraq so that, with a change of administration there can be no change of policy. He also continues to try to set the Executive Branch above the law. You should click through to the Boston Globe story to see the photo of Bush with Cheney smirking in the background. It’s sort of creepy.

    My benchmark for these matters of executive power and privilege is usually to point out that what this President sets as precedent, future presidents will take as privilege. And do you want Hillary Clinton or Barack Obama or John McCain or Mitt Romney or Mike Huckabee to be able to set themselves above the law?

    It’s not enough to hunker down and wait for Bush to be replaced by somebody more sane (and on the subject of war I’m not sure I’d put John McCain in that category). I think we need to be fighting some of this stuff pretty hard right now. The man still has a year in office.

    See also The Sideshow on the bottom line implication of what Bush has done:

    Bush has now declared that he has the power to decide whether Congress can control the purse strings. He also says they can’t stop him from building permanent bases in Iraq, a tacit admission that he’s been lying all along about not building them. He also says Congress can’t stop him from stealing Iraq’s oil.

    Possibly related posts:

      Must reads
      When lawyers authorize torture
      The Bill of Rights

    Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

2 Responses to “Above the Law?”

  1. Caught the Clinton-Obama debate on CNN last night.

    One of the things Clinton said was that GW thinks he only needs the Iraqis’ permission to build bases in Iraq. He totally ignores the Congress when it suits him.

    No president should have this power. I would hope that Clinton would stand by her statement and not follow Bush down that path, but I doubt it.

    I would also hope that any Democrat would not hope for a foreign war in perpetuity.

    But we’ll just have to see.

    Love,

    T

  2. I don’t think any of these candidates, if elected, will get us out of Iraq very quickly, Tommy. I think the reality of the mess Bush has made will prevent that. I do hope, however, that Bush isn’t allowed to make commitments for long-term involvement that tie the hands of the next administration. How to stop him is beyond me, however. He recognizes no restraints and so he has none.

    But war is war and unpredictable. In the end, I think it’ll take something like Tet to get us out. And that could happen any time.

Leave a Reply

 
RSS feed

Archives

Categories

Recent Comments

  • Gin: When you find out what that last flower is, please tell me. Each spring I fight it in the gravel at the edge of our drive. Nice little...
  • Jessie carty: Now I’m hungry!
  • Georgia Green Stamper: Beautiful photos, TR & Sherry. Beautiful.
  • Georgia Green Stamper: You have rhubarb? Where were you last spring when Barbara Kingsolver and I needed you? -:)
  • Jessie Carty: i finished reading an Einstein biography within days of his birthday! how cool is that ;)

Theme Switcher

What I'm Doing...

  • Drizzle is a miserable word. The heavens lower, my mood is dour. A little spring and I would sing. The sun would turn me carefree as a bird. 1 day ago
  • I open the back door and the wren flies at shin level. Is she nesting on the porch? Our cats are old but not that old. 3 days ago
  • The dark spot high in the cherry swells like a lung, fanned wings, fanned tail, shrinks and resolves into a common grackle. 3 days ago
  • A great business of birds in the trees and on the grass. Spring is late and like Casey Jones they need to see those drivers roll. 5 days ago
  • More updates...

Powered by Twitter Tools

 
my 'read' shelf:
 my read shelf

Sherry's favorite quotes


"Art is not about itself but the attention we bring to it."— Marcel Duchamp

Artistic Support

Sherry Chandler has received professional development funding and a Professional Assistance Award through the Kentucky Arts Council, the state arts agency, supported by state tax dollars and federal funding from the National Endowment for the Arts. Kentucky Arts Council Sherry has also received an Artist Enrichment grant from the Kentucky Foundation for Women. kfw
CURRENT MOON