Sherry Chandler » More on the Prayer Study
More on the Prayer Study
from an Op-Ed in the NYTimes by Raymond J. Lawrence, director of pastoral care at New York Presbyterian:
RESPONSIBLE religious leaders will breathe a sigh of relief at the news that so-called intercessory prayer is medically ineffective. In a large and much touted scientific study, one group of patients was told that strangers would pray for them, a second group was told strangers might or might not pray for them, and a third group was not prayed for at all. The $2.4 million study found that the strangers’ prayers did not help patients’ recovery.
The results of the study, led by Dr. Herbert Benson, a cardiologist and director of the Mind/Body Medical Institute near Boston, came as welcome news. That may sound odd coming from an ordained minister. But if it could ever be persuasively demonstrated that such prayer “works,” our religious institutions and meeting places would be degraded to a kind of commercial enterprise, like Burger King, where one expects to get what one pays for.
Historically, religions have promoted many kinds of prayer. Prayers of praise, thanksgiving and repentance have been highly esteemed, while intercessions of the kind done in the Benson study — appeals to God to take some action — are of lesser importance. They represent a less-respected magical wing of religion.
…The Lord’s Prayer, the central prayer of Christendom, contains no plea for God to influence specific events in people’s lives.
My thanks to Mr. Lawrence who has articulated better than I can my dis-ease with prayer lists.
Possibly related posts:
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.
Leave a comment